Comparative Comparison of New and Old Neighborhoods of Isfahan City Based on the Iranian-Islamic City Approach (Case Study: Shahshahan and Baharestan Neighborhoods)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Department of Geography and Urban Planning, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.

2 Ph.D student of Urban Planning Geography, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.

Abstract

In recent decades, Iranian Islamic cities have been heavily influenced by globalization, which has led to transformation and creating ambiguities in their physical manifestation. Due to the spread of foreign culture, this metamorphosis has moved away from the basic guidelines of the revealed teachings in the construction of the Iranian Islamic city and has brought about significant changes in the urban structure. Therefore, the main goal of the current research is the comparative comparison of the new and old neighborhoods of Isfahan based on the Iranian-Islamic city approach. Therefore, two neighborhoods (the old neighborhood of Shahshahan and the new neighborhood of Baharestan) were selected in the city of Isfahan. In this context, 39 indicators were selected in the form of four principles: mosque-centered (man's relationship with God), introversion (man's relationship with himself), neighborhood-centered (man's relationship with society) and naturalism (man's relationship with the universe). In the next step, research data was collected using the questionnaire technique and field studies. In the next step, the collected data was entered into spss software. Finally, the status of the two studied neighborhoods in terms of the indicators of the Iranian Islamic city was compared using an independent t-test. The results of the statistical analysis showed that the average of the two groups in the two studied neighborhoods have significant differences in 23 indicators, and also the average of the majority of indicators in Shahshahan neighborhood is much higher than Baharestan neighborhood. The biggest difference between the two studied neighborhoods is in mosque-oriented, introspective, neighborhood-oriented, and lastly, naturalism. An important point is that these two neighborhoods have very little difference in the nature aspect, apart from the two indicators of the presence of a yard in the house and the presence of a garden in the yard of the residential unit.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Ansari, Ibrahim. (2002). The social position of the neighborhood in Islamic cities with emphasis on Isfahan. Isfahan University Humanities Research Journal, 13(1), 15-26. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/24884/fa
    Apaydin, M. (2015). Reframing the Islamic city: From definition to deconstruction. The Maghreb Review, 40(4), 473-492. https://doi.org/10.1353/tmr.2015.0034
 Ashibabandan, Amir Mohammad (2010) The mosque and its place in the image of the Islamic city, Panjreh Quarterly, 2(8), 56-57. (In Persian)
 Aslani (2015), evaluation of compliance with the Islamic-Iranian city model in new cities, a case study of the new city of Sahand., Master's thesis in the field of geography and urban planning, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Mohaghegh Ardabili University. (In Persian)
 Bahri Moghadam, Abbas, and Yousefi Far, Shahram. (2012). Socio-cultural factors in the formation of the neighborhood in the Iranian-Islamic city and its functions. Islamic History and Civilization, 9(17), 101-116. (In Persian) https://sid.ir/paper/157232/fa
Bemanian, M. (2013). Islamic Iranian city: meaning and conceptualization of the Iranian-Islamic city, theoretical foundations and examples. National Conference on Urban Planning and Management. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/836052
    Correia, J., & Taher, M. (2015). Traditional Islamic cities unveiled: the quest for urban design regularity.https://hdl.handle.net/1822/44223.
 Cultural and social birth certificate of neighborhoods of Isfahan city, (2015) publications of Isfahan municipality's cultural and recreational organization, the work of Isfahan city cultural and social observatory commissioned by the cultural and social deputy.
    Dabbour, L. M. (2021). Morphology of quarters in traditional Arab Islamic city: A case of the traditional city of Damascus. Frontiers of Architectural Research, 10(1), 50-65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foar.2020.11.004
Daneshvari, A., Ettehad, S. S., & Javadi, G. (2020). A framework for modeling and quantitative assessment of urban pattern compatibility with qualitative indices and elements of the Iranian-Islamic city using GIS. Geographical Planning of Space, 10(35), 127-144. (In Persian)doi: doi:10.30488/gps.2020.100910
Daneshvari, Ali; Etehad, Sayeda Shabnaz; Javadi, Qasim. (2019). Providing a framework for modeling and quantitative evaluation of the degree of compatibility of the urban form pattern with the qualitative indicators and components of the Iranian-Islamic city with the help of GIS. Journal of Geographical Survey of Space, 10(35), 127-144. (In Persian)doi: 10.30488/gps.2020.100910
Delir, Ismail; Masoumi, Mohammad Taghi; Samadzadeh, Rasul. (1400). Ranking the degree of conformity and proximity of the urban areas of Ardabil city with the elements involved in the emergence of an authentic Islamic city. Geography and Regional Urban Planning, 11(41), 221-252. (In Persian)doi: 10.22111/gaij.2021.6657
 Ghasemi, Zahra (2017) Evaluation of the new city of Hashtgerd based on the characteristics of Iranian and Islamic urban planning, master's thesis in the field of geography and urban planning, Tarbiat Modares University, Faculty of Literature and Human Sciences. (In Persian)
 Hataminejad, Hossein; Zinali, Suleiman; Zinali, Mohammad Ali (2013) The Islamic city is a suitable model for establishing social justice and achieving sustainable development, Proceedings of the Second National Islamic City Conference, Isfahan, 451-1. (In Persian)https://civilica.com/doc/242632/
 Jahanbakhsh, Haider, Lotfi Poursiahkhlorodi, Morteza, and Zakipour, Najmeh. (2016). Investigating the transformation of the nature of the realm of activism, from the Iranian-Islamic city to the contemporary Iranian city. Iranian Islamic City Studies, 8(30), 31-41. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/513992/fa
 Karimi, Ramin (2014) An easy guide to statistical analysis with spss, Tehran: Hengam. (In Persian)
 Khodayi, Zahra, and Taqvai, Ali Akbar. (1390). Personality of the Islamic city; Emphasizing the physical dimensions of the Islamic city. Iranian Islamic City Studies, 2(5), 103-113. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/177413/fa
Latifi, Gholamreza, and Safari Chabak, Neda. (2012). Re-creating the neighborhood concept in Iranian-Islamic cities based on the principles of neo-urbanism. Social Science Quarterly, -(66), 58-66. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/493162/fa
 Mansouri, Ali. (2010). Hijab and veiling in Iranian-Islamic urban planning, a sample of field research: the ancient context of Shiraz city. Housing and Village Environment, 29(130), 38-49. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/185996/fa
    Marçais, W. (1928). L'Islamisme et la vie urbaine. Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, 72(1), 86-100.‏ https://doi.org/10.3406/crai.1928.75567
 Memarian, Gholamhossein (2004) A journey through the theoretical foundations of architecture, Tehran: Soroush Danesh Publications. (In Persian)
 Meshkini Abolfazl; Hamzenejad, Mehdi, Ghasemi, Akram (2012) Geographical and cultural foundations of introversion and privacy in Islamic architecture and urban planning (case study: the old context of Isfahan city), the first national conference on architecture, restoration, urban planning and sustainable environment, Hamadan. (In Persian)https: //civilica.com/doc/263409    
Meshkini, A., Hamzenejad, M., and Ghasemi, K. (2015). conceptual refining and solutions (strategies) description and substantiation indicators of four principles of mosque based, neighborhood based, introversion and naturalism in iranian-islamic city. journal of researches in islamic architecture, 3(3 (8)), 34-35. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/395233/en
Meshkini, Abolfazl, and Rezaei Moghadam, Ali. (2013). Iranian Islamic City: Examining the components and indicators of the Islamic city with an emphasis on the role and importance of culture building in the realization of the Iranian Islamic city-building model. National Conference on Urban Planning and Management. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/836060/fa
 Meshkini, Abolfazl, Ghasemi, Akram, and Hamzenejad, Mahdi. (2015). Evaluation of the new city of Hashtgerd based on the principles of Islamic Iranian urban planning. National Studies, 17(4 (68)), 39-58. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/500075/fa
 Meshkini, Abolfazl, Hamzenejad, Mehdi, and Ghasemi, Kimia. (2014). Conceptual clarification and description of solutions and indicators for the realization of the four principles of mosque-centered, neighborhood-centered, introversion and naturalism in the Iranian Islamic city. Researches on Islamic Architecture, 3(3 (consecutive 8)), 18-33. (In Persian) https://sid.ir/paper/395233/fa
Mohammadi, J, & Azadeh, S. R. (2019). Comparative Comparison of New and Old Neighborhoods of Isfahan in terms of Adaptability to Iranian-Islamic Indicators Case Study: Isfahan Juybareh neighborhoods and Negin town. Journal of studies on iranian islamic city, 9(34 ), 23-34. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/177417/en
 Mohammadi, Jamal, and Azadeh, Seyedreza. (2017). A comparative comparison of the new and old neighborhoods of Isfahan in terms of the degree of adaptability to Islamic Iranian indicators, a case study: Joibareh and Nagin neighborhoods. Iranian Islamic City Studies, 9(34), 23-34. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/177417/fa
 Motavali, Sadruddin, and Sheikh Azami, Ali. (2012). The evolution of traditional urban spaces in Iranian-Islamic cities; From pre-modernism to post-modernism. Iranian Islamic City Studies, -(14), 51-62. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/177395/fa
    Mumford, Lewis (1961). The City in History: Its Origins, Its Transformations, and Its Prospects. Science and Society 27 (1):106-109.https://ci.nii.ac.jp/ncid/BA04979663?l=en
 Muyidi, Mohammad; Daneshpour, Abdul Hadi (2012), Searching for the constituent elements of the Islamic city in the Holy Quran and its social reflection in the body of the city, Second Conference on Islamic Utopia, Volume II, Isfahan Municipality. (In Persian)
 Naghizadeh, Mohammad, (2012), Model, foundations, pillars, attributes and principles of the Islamic city, Firuzeh Islam magazine, 1(1), 63-80. (In Persian)http://dx.doi.org/10.29252/ciauj.1.1 .63
 Naghizadeh, Mohammad, (2013), Islamic city and the method of using holy texts, Kitab Mah Honar, (177), 24-35. (In Persian)http://noo.rs/pDi5h
    Neglia, G. A. (2008). Some historiographical notes on the Islamic city with particular reference to the visual representation of the built city. In The City in the Islamic World (2 vols.) (pp. 1-46). Brill.https://doi.org/10.1163/ej.9789004162402.i-1500.6
Okhovat, H, Almasifar, T; Bemanian, M (2009) Traditional architecture and urban planning in Islamic countries, first edition, Tehran: Tahan Publications.
    Orum, A. M. (2019). The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Urban and Regional Studies. John Wiley & Sons.‏ DOI: 10.1002/9781118568446
Pour Ahmad, Ahmad, Vafaie, Abuzar (2016). The impact of modernism on the physical-spatial structure of the Iranian-Islamic city (case study: Kashan city), Iranian Islamic City Studies Quarterly, 7(28), 63-76. (In Persian)magiran.com/p1780234
 Pourhossein Roshan, Hamid; Mohammadpour, Saber, (2013), Islamic city with an emphasis on the central council paradigm (comparative comparison - relational approach and council theory in Islam), the second conference of Islamic Utopia, first volume, Isfahan Municipality. (In Persian)
 Pourjafar, Mohammad Reza, Pourjafar, Ali, and Safdari, Sima. (2014). Types of Islamic cities and references to indexing in the direction of an ideal-Islamic city. Researches on Islamic Architecture, 3(3 (consecutive 8)), 17-3. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/409703/fa
Pourmohammadi, M., Bahrain, S.H. and Davoudpour, Z. (2019). Islamic city: fantasy or reality. Urban Planning Knowledge, 3(2), 33-47. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/269027/en
 Pourmohammadi, Marzieh, Bahraini, Seyed Hossein, and Dawoodpour, Zahra. (2018). Islamic city: imagination or reality. Knowledge of Urbanization, 3(2), 33-47. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/269027/fa
 Qaraiti, Mohsen, (2013), Simai Maskan and Islamic City, first edition, Qom, Publications of the Cultural Center of Lessons from the Qur'an, volume one. (In Persian)
    Rozhan, A., Yunos, M. Y. M., Isa, N. K. M., Ariffin, N. F. M., Kamil, S. M., Azmee, N., & Abas, A. S. (2016). Analysis Of Islamic Safe City Planning Concept For A Better Living Environment. Research journal of fisheries and hydrobiology, 11(3), 69-73. http://www.aensiweb.net/AENSIWEB/rjfh/rjfh/2016/March/69-73.pdf
Safaee Pour, M., & Saeedi, J. (2017). A Historical Analysis of the Elements and physical-spatial structure of Iranian-Islamic Cities. Journal of Islam and Social Studies, 5(19), 95-125. doi: 10.22081/jiss.2017.65554
 Safaipour, Masoud, Sajjadian, Mahyar. (2014). . (2014). A research on the developments and developments of the Islamic city concept. Geographical Journal of Zagros Landscape, 7(24), 159-205. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/515017/fa
 Safaipour, Massoud; (2014) Urban Planning in Iran, Karaj: Nibag Publishing. (In Persian)
 Safaipour, Massoud; Saidi, Jafar. (2016). A historical analysis on the elements and spatial physical structure of Iranian-Islamic cities. Islam and Social Studies, 5(No. 3 (Serial 19)), 95-125. (In Persian) doi: 10.22081/jiss.2017.65554
 Safaipour, Massoud; Sajjadian Mehyar (1401) Foundations of Islamic cities (with emphasis on the pre-modern period), Ahvaz: Ahvaz Shahid Chamran University Publications. (In Persian)
Seifian, Mohammad Kazem, and Mahmoudi, Mohammad Reza. (2007). Privacy in traditional Iranian architecture. City Identity, 1(1), 3-14. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/501753/fa
 Shafaqi, Siros, (2013), Spatial Structure of the Islamic City and its Security, Second Islamic Utopia Conference, Volume 1, Isfahan Municipality. (In Persian)
 Shams Puya, Mohammad Kazem; Meshkini, Abolfazl; Bergmadi, Mojtabi (2019) Application of Islamic worldview in Iranian-Islamic cities with an emphasis on sustainable neighborhood development, Zagros Landscape Geography and Urban Planning Quarterly, 12 (43), 73-93. (In Persian)https://civilica.com/doc/1495809
 Sharifian, Ehsan, Pourjafar, Mohammad Reza, and Tagwai, Ali Akbar. (2016). An analysis of the concept of the city and the pillars of urbanization from the perspective of the Holy Quran. City Identity, 11(29), 53-66. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/154699/fa
    Smith, M. E. (2010). The archaeological study of neighborhoods and districts in ancient cities. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 29(2), 137-154. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaa.2010.01.001
 Statistics of Isfahan City (2019), Isfahan Municipality Program and Budget Organization. (In Persian)
Statistics of Isfahan City (2019), Isfahan Municipality Program and Budget Organization. (In Persian)
 Tagvaiee, Ali Akbar, and Maroufi, Sakineh. (2010). Evaluating the role of mosques in improving the quality of the environment, case study: Amir Mosque in Tehran. Urban Management, 8(25), 219-234. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/92230/fa
 Zargham Fard, Muslim, Meshkini, Abolfazl, Pourahmad, Ahmed, and Morganti, Benjamin. (2018). Reviewing the indicators of decent housing from the perspective of the Islamic school. Iranian Islamic City Studies, 9(35), 33-45. (In Persian)https://sid.ir/paper/177370/fa
 Zarrabi, Asghar; Alinejad Tayibi, Kavos, (2009), an analysis of urban elements and uses in an Islamic city, Kitab Mah Honar monthly, serial 143. (In Persian)magiran.com/p766044
 Pirnia, Mohammad Karim (2002); Architectural stylistics, Tehran: Memar Publishing House(In Persian).
 Pirnia, Mohammad Karim and Gholamhossein Memarian (2007); Stylistics of Iranian Architecture, Soroush Danesh Publications, Tehran: 5th edition. (In Persian)
Motahar, Reza Jalili Sadrabad, Samaneh Alizadeh, Reza (1400) comparative comparison of new and old neighborhoods based on (Islamic-Iranian) identity in urban planning (Study example: Hakimieh and Narmak Shahr Tehran), Journal of Islamic Architecture Research, 9 (3) (In Persian). http://jria.iust.ac.ir/article-1-1419-fa.html